Google
Web pcflank.com
PC Flank Logo
Make sure
you're protected
on all sides
 Test Your System
 Ask the experts
 Security Center

 

Tip of the day
If you use Windows, regularly check for new security patches from Microsoft.

Articles Library

The "Real world" anti-trojan tools comparison

Comparison results
Here are the results of our testing:



  Software Trojans detected Detection rate
  Kaspersky Antivirus   242 of 256 94.5%
  Tauscan   241 of 256 94.1%
  TrojanRemover   237 of 256 92.5%
  Trojan Defence Suite (TDS)   235 of 256 91.7%
  Dr. Web   233 of 256 91.0%
  Norton Antivirus   219 of 256 85.5%
  The Cleaner   215 of 256 83.9%
  Antiy Ghostbusters   212 of 256 82.8%
  NOD32   205 of 256 80.0%
  PC DoorGuard   197 of 256 76.9%
  Digital Patrol   192 of 256 75.0%
  PestPatrol   185 of 256 72.2%
  AntiTrojan   135 of 256 52.7%
  TrojanHunter   133 of 256 51.9%


You can also download log-files of tested products. Click here to download zip-file. Please note that Antiy Ghostbusters does not have feature for saving log-files and was not included to logs file.

Comments on results:

  • Only five tools were able to detect more than 90% of trojans. Those tools are: Kaspersky Antivirus, Tauscan, TrojanRemover, Trojan Defence Suite (TDS), Dr. Web. These tools will likely find 9 of 10 trojan horses on your system.
  • Still (and this is inevitable fact) there are no applications which are able to receive 100% detection rate meaning users still have to use third party programs like personal firewalls to protect their computers against trojan horses.
  • AntiTrojan and Trojan Hunter have hardly surpassed 50% mark what questions detections rate of these tools.
  • Norton Antivirus (as well as some other tools) improved its trojan detection rate comparing to our previous comparison.
  • We have informed all developers about this comparison and sent them a link to trojans archive to let them update their trojan signatures.
Our recommendations to the users:

Regarding all five leaders showed almost equeal results users are left to choose one of those five tools.

To users, who prefer simple user-friendly interface and ease of use, we advice to choose Tauscan or Dr. Web. These products are the best anti-trojan tools for rookie users. We do not include TrojanRemover to this list as its interface seemed very unfriendly to us. However its detection rate makes it worth using if you do not pay much attention to interface and ease of use.

More advanced users, who appreciate a functionality of the program and prefer keeping the system under their full control will likely find Kaspersky Antivirus or Trojan Defence Suite (TDS) more attractive. These products are the best anti-trojan tools for advanced users.

tested on July 3, 2002

back to:
"AntiTrojan Tools Introduction"
"AntiTrojan Tools Overview"

 
 
Start Page
Make "PC Flank" your   
Start Page!   
Make

 
Sponsored links


   
 
Related Links
» How To Protect Your Computer From Attacks

» What is a Trojan Horse's Trapdoor?
   
 

 
   
Outpost Firewall PRO 3.0 - complete protection on the Internet!

Secure Internet surfing with Oupost personal firewall with antispyware and free firewall available for download at www.agnitum.com.
 
Privacy Policy
    Advertiser Info
Site Map
    Contact Us

 
 
© 2006 PC Flank Ltd. All rights reserved.